Follow ACMA
Twitter Facebook Linkedin Twitter
v
GO
Updates & Calls to Action
PUBLIC POLICY UPDATES

Court Certifies Nationwide Class in “Observation Status” Case


Posted on: 8/4/2017

Decision in Alexander v. Price Means Medicare Patients Could Gain Right to Appeal Placement on “Observation Status” and Avoid Large Medical Bills

Eighty-four-year-old Nancy Niemi of North Carolina was hospitalized for 39 days earlier this year after her doctor sent her to the emergency room. It took weeks to stabilize her blood pressure and she experienced serious complications. But unbelievably, Ms. Niemi was categorized as an outpatient on “observation status” for her entire hospitalization, and she therefore lacked the three-day inpatient stay Medicare requires for coverage of her subsequent, very expensive care at a nursing home. Ms. Niemi’s son tried to help her challenge her lengthy placement on observation status, but Medicare does not allow beneficiaries to appeal this issue. She still owes thousands of dollars to the nursing facility. However, due to the federal court decision issued July 31, 2017, she is now a member of a nationwide class of hospital patients who may gain the right to appeal their placement on observation status.

In Alexander v. Price, 3:11-CV-1703 (MPS) (formerly captioned Barrows v. Burwell), Judge Michael P. Shea of U.S. District Court in Connecticut, certified a class composed of all Medicare beneficiaries who, since January 1, 2009, have received or will have received “observation services” as an outpatient during a hospitalization. The late Martha Leyanna of Delaware, for example, one of the named plaintiffs in the case, had to pay thousands of dollars for nursing facility care after being hospitalized for six days on observation status. "My mother was treated just like she was inpatient,” her daughter Mary Smith explained, “but she was never allowed to try to prove her case to Medicare. It was very unfair."

Class members are likely to number in the hundreds of thousands. The court cited a 2012 study by researchers at Brown University that identified 918,180 Medicare beneficiaries who experienced observation stays in 2009 alone. In addition to lacking coverage for very costly nursing home care, patients on observation status can also face increased costs for drugs taken at the hospital and copayments for hospital services, as noted by a recent report from the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of the Inspector General. Alice Bers, Litigation Director of the Center for Medicare Advocacy, said that certification of the class is a critical step in creating a fair opportunity to be heard for hospital patients, who can face severe financial and health consequences if they are placed on observation status. "The decision recognizes that Medicare patients across the country face dire situations, including having to choose between spending thousands of dollars on nursing home care or simply forgoing that necessary care. We look forward to establishing that the right to review is required as a matter of constitutional due process."

In addition to attorneys from the Center for Medicare Advocacy, the class is also represented by attorneys from Justice in Aging and from the law firm of Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati. The court had previously allowed the case to proceed in a decision issued in February 2017.

Click here to read the full order.

Return to Legislative Postings

Announcements

Your Gift Today Helps Patients and Families

ACMA is dedicated to transforming the nation’s health care through the power of case management. We find and fund new ways to solve problems, generate new ideas and tools and lay the framework to improve patient care outcomes across the continuum of care. To continue the critical work that we do, we rely on donations. Help ACMA advocate for you by donating on #GivingTuesday, taking place this year on November 27. Donate Today >>>

ACMA Legislative Campaign: Close the Medicare Observation Coverage Gap

We need your help! Raise your voice in support of the "Improving Access to Medicare Coverage Act" and our campaign to close the observation status coverage gap in Medicare.
Take Action    Sign the Petition!

Compass 2019 is Coming Soon: Save by December 31

Build a competent and confident care team with Compass training for 2019! This comprehensive program is designed to standardize onboarding and competency validation for case managers and physician advisors. New courses include an introduction to health plan case management, ethics and scenarios for continuum-based care. Courses are now designated as “Core” or “Specialty” to highlight learning applicable to case managers in multiple settings across the continuum of care, with additional learning focused on the unique needs of specific specialties, such as pediatrics, health plans and advanced/leadership training. Purchase upgrade or learn more today>>>.

Save the Date: 2019 Leadership and Physician Advisor Conference

The 2018 Leadership and Physician Advisor Conference took place early November in Huntington Beach, California! Case management leaders and physician advisors from across the country gathered to collaborate, network and move case management forward. Follow #ACMAleadership on social media to see all the action that took place. We hope you'll join us next year, November 14-17, 2019 in Miami, Florida!

New Simulation Program for Value-Based Results

ACMA leads the practice by introducing Advanced Care Transitions Simulation (ACTS). This simulation program will transform orientation and professional development for your case management team. ACTS is focused on improving care transitions through assessment, communication, planning and collaboration. It leverages unique, team-based simulations of patient scenarios and enhances care coordination and critical thinking. Enhance case management and impact your system with ACTS. >>>

Congress Passes Opioid Bill, President to Sign

Great news from Washington! With your support, Congress took a historic step in the fight against the opioid epidemic. On Wednesday, October 4, Congress approved the comprehensive opioids response package, sending the bill to President Trump for his signature and enactment into law. Read more here >>>

American Case Management Association
11701 W. 36th St.
Little Rock, Arkansas 72211
Phone: 501-907-ACMA (2262)
Fax: 501-227-4247