Follow ACMA
Twitter Facebook Linkedin
v
GO
Updates & Calls to ActionMake a Donation
PUBLIC POLICY UPDATES

Court Certifies Nationwide Class in “Observation Status” Case


Posted on: 8/4/2017

Decision in Alexander v. Price Means Medicare Patients Could Gain Right to Appeal Placement on “Observation Status” and Avoid Large Medical Bills

Eighty-four-year-old Nancy Niemi of North Carolina was hospitalized for 39 days earlier this year after her doctor sent her to the emergency room. It took weeks to stabilize her blood pressure and she experienced serious complications. But unbelievably, Ms. Niemi was categorized as an outpatient on “observation status” for her entire hospitalization, and she therefore lacked the three-day inpatient stay Medicare requires for coverage of her subsequent, very expensive care at a nursing home. Ms. Niemi’s son tried to help her challenge her lengthy placement on observation status, but Medicare does not allow beneficiaries to appeal this issue. She still owes thousands of dollars to the nursing facility. However, due to the federal court decision issued July 31, 2017, she is now a member of a nationwide class of hospital patients who may gain the right to appeal their placement on observation status.

In Alexander v. Price, 3:11-CV-1703 (MPS) (formerly captioned Barrows v. Burwell), Judge Michael P. Shea of U.S. District Court in Connecticut, certified a class composed of all Medicare beneficiaries who, since January 1, 2009, have received or will have received “observation services” as an outpatient during a hospitalization. The late Martha Leyanna of Delaware, for example, one of the named plaintiffs in the case, had to pay thousands of dollars for nursing facility care after being hospitalized for six days on observation status. "My mother was treated just like she was inpatient,” her daughter Mary Smith explained, “but she was never allowed to try to prove her case to Medicare. It was very unfair."

Class members are likely to number in the hundreds of thousands. The court cited a 2012 study by researchers at Brown University that identified 918,180 Medicare beneficiaries who experienced observation stays in 2009 alone. In addition to lacking coverage for very costly nursing home care, patients on observation status can also face increased costs for drugs taken at the hospital and copayments for hospital services, as noted by a recent report from the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of the Inspector General. Alice Bers, Litigation Director of the Center for Medicare Advocacy, said that certification of the class is a critical step in creating a fair opportunity to be heard for hospital patients, who can face severe financial and health consequences if they are placed on observation status. "The decision recognizes that Medicare patients across the country face dire situations, including having to choose between spending thousands of dollars on nursing home care or simply forgoing that necessary care. We look forward to establishing that the right to review is required as a matter of constitutional due process."

In addition to attorneys from the Center for Medicare Advocacy, the class is also represented by attorneys from Justice in Aging and from the law firm of Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati. The court had previously allowed the case to proceed in a decision issued in February 2017.

Click here to read the full order.

Return to Legislative Postings

Announcements

COVID-19 Updates and Resources

ACMA members play an important role as a patient advocate to the organizations and communities they serve. We are thinking of you during these unprecedented times. Stay tuned for updates and resources about COVID-19. Learn More >>>

Members-Only COVID-19 Resource Center

The current COVID-19 pandemic continues to create worldwide concern. Here you will find helpful information, members-only resources and guidance for case management and transitions of care specific to this evolving situation. We encourage you to visit the resource center and to lean on ACMA as your trusted source during this time of uncertainty. Thank you for your work in your communities and for all you are doing to address this pandemic. Access Members-Only COVID-19 Resources >>>

National Conference Presentations: Deadline Extended to June 5

What tips and best practices could you share with case management professionals to implement into their practice? Submit your presentation for the 2021 National Conference in Orlando, April 11–14. The deadline is extended to Friday, June 5. Submit your presentation. Submit Now >>>

2020 ACMA Virtual National Conference: Adapt. Innovate. Elevate.

We know many of you were looking forward to the 2020 ACMA National Conference in Chicago. The COVID-19 outbreak, however, has forced us all to adapt and use innovative ways to rise above so we can continue to elevate our practice. ACMA is adapting with you to bring education and networking directly to you. The 2020 ACMA Virtual National Conference—including on-demand education and exhibitor resources—will be offered this summer and we hope you will choose to be part of this new and innovative experience. Get a sneak peek at the speakers and topics confirmed thus far. Registration will be opening soon. Meet the Speakers >>>

2021 ACMA National Conference Location Announced

We hope you will join us for the 28th Annual National Case Management and Transitions of Care Conference and 22nd Annual ACMA Meeting in Orlando. The 2021 ACMA National Conference will take place April 11-14 at the Orlando World Center Marriott. Learn More >>>

Validate Your Expertise Through Professional Certification

The Accredited Case Manager (ACM) Certification is for health care delivery system case management professionals and tests core case management knowledge that is shared by nurse and social work case managers. Case Management Administrator Certification (CMAC) validates the competency of case management administrators, managers and aspiring leaders and promotes professional practice standards. If you are not yet certified, we encourage you to apply and enhance your professional practice by putting a credential after your name. The application deadline is August 15 in order to test in October-December. ACM >>> CMAC >>>

Educate Your Staff Safely and Conveniently with Compass

ACMA is here for you during this challenging and unprecedented time. Having a well-trained and knowledgeable staff is critical but is harder than ever in today's environment. Compass online learning system not only teaches and tests solid foundational knowledge in case management and physician advisory practices, but it also offers a safe pathway to standardized training, as all courses can be completed without ever leaving your facility. Now until August 1, new customers enjoy 50% off annual fees with a 3-year commitment. Learn more and subscribe now. >>>

American Case Management Association
11701 W. 36th St.
Little Rock, Arkansas 72211
Phone: 501-907-ACMA (2262)
Fax: 501-227-4247